Sinister Shepherd: The Two Wives A.B. Schirmer Allegedly Killed
This article tells the haunting story of A.B. Schirmer, a once-trusted Pennsylvania pastor whose two wives died under suspicious circumstances. Through a gripping narrative style, the article recounts Schirmer’s life—from his early ministry to the deaths of Jewel and Betty Schirmer, and the trials that followed.
His case uncovers a dark truth: even the most trusted figures can carry deadly secrets. This story blends emotional storytelling, crime investigation, and psychological depth, all while staying accessible and transparent. It explores betrayal, love, faith, and the pursuit of justice.
When Trust Turns Deadly
For years, Arthur Burton Schirmer stood behind the pulpit, preaching hope, love, and salvation. His congregation looked up to him. He was soft-spoken, devout, and married to a kind, supportive woman.
But behind his calm sermons and caring image was a secret life filled with lies, betrayal, and, ultimately, murder. Two of his wives died under strange circumstances—almost a decade apart. At first, their deaths seemed like tragic accidents. However, when investigators began asking questions, a darker truth started to emerge.
A.B. Schirmer’s Early Life and Ministry
Arthur Burton Schirmer was born on May 1, 1948. He grew up in Pennsylvania in a deeply religious home. From a young age, he felt drawn to the church. He studied theology and began preaching as a young man. Over time, he became a well-known pastor in central Pennsylvania, eventually serving at Bethany United Methodist Church in Lebanon.
His sermons were heartfelt. His community respected him. People turned to him in times of grief and celebration. To many, he was more than a pastor—he was a spiritual leader, a counselor, and a friend. He married Jewel Schirmer, and together they raised a family. For years, everything looked picture-perfect. But darkness lingered in the background.
The First Wife: Jewel’s Mysterious Death
In April 1999, tragedy struck. Schirmer told authorities that Jewel had fallen down a flight of basement stairs while vacuuming. He claimed he found her unconscious, tangled in the cord. She was rushed to the hospital but died the next day from severe head injuries.
At the time, her death was ruled “undetermined.” No one pressed further. Jewel’s family mourned, confused but unaware of anything suspicious. The community prayed for the pastor and moved on. But the truth, as it would later turn out, had only begun to unravel.
The Second Wife: A Fatal Crash That Didn’t Add Up
Almost a decade later, in July 2008, tragedy struck again. Schirmer was now remarried—to Betty Schirmer. According to him, they were driving early one morning when he swerved to avoid a deer, causing the car to hit a guardrail. Betty died from severe head trauma. Once again, the scene appeared to be a tragic accident.
But investigators noticed something odd. The damage to the vehicle didn’t match Betty’s injuries. Her head trauma was far too severe for a low-speed crash. There were also signs of blood spatter in their garage, suggesting she might have been attacked before being placed in the car. It marked the beginning of a lengthy and complex investigation.
A Scandal That Sparked Suspicion
What triggered the deeper probe into Betty’s death wasn’t just the inconsistent crash scene. A few months after her passing, a man named Joe Musante—husband of the church secretary—died by suicide in the pastor’s office. He had discovered that Schirmer was having an affair with his wife, Cindy. That discovery became the turning point.
Joe’s death, Betty’s mysterious injuries, and Schirmer’s suspicious behavior began to draw attention. Police reopened Betty’s case. They started digging deeper—not just into the crash but also into Schirmer’s past.
The Truth Behind the Smile
As detectives pulled back the curtain on Schirmer’s life, more disturbing details came to light. Forensic experts re-examined Jewel’s 1999 death and determined her injuries were inconsistent with a fall down stairs. Instead, they found signs of blunt-force trauma, possibly caused by a heavy object.
Schirmer, who once offered comfort to grieving families, was now the focus of a murder investigation. His church community was stunned. Friends who had trusted him for years felt betrayed. The man who once led prayers was now facing murder charges.
Trial and Sentencing: Justice for Jewel and Betty
In January 2013, Schirmer went to trial for Betty’s murder. Prosecutors argued that he had beaten her with a crowbar or similar object before staging the car crash. The jury didn’t take long to reach a decision. He was found guilty of first-degree murder and sentenced to life in prison without parole.
But that wasn’t the end. In 2014, Schirmer was also charged with the death of his first wife, Jewel. This time, he entered a no-contest plea to third-degree murder. He received an additional 20 to 40 years in prison.
Though he continued to claim innocence, the evidence had caught up to him. In court, Jewel’s brother expressed the family’s pain: “You destroyed so many lives, and you never looked back.” Schirmer simply responded, “I am not a murderer.”
The Aftermath: A Fallen Leader Behind Bars
Today, A.B. Schirmer is serving his sentence in a Pennsylvania state prison. His name is now linked with betrayal, deceit, and murder. His case has been featured in multiple true-crime shows, where forensic experts and family members recount the chilling story.
For the communities he served, the wounds are still fresh. People still wrestle with the question: How could a man of faith do something so horrific? The scars left behind are not just emotional—they are spiritual, communal, and generational.
Final Words: When Faith Becomes a Mask
The story of A.B. Schirmer isn’t just about crime—it’s about the false comfort of appearances. It’s about a man who used faith and kindness as a shield for evil. For two women who trusted him, it cost them their lives. For their families, it brought years of confusion, grief, and finally, justice.
In a world where we often believe what we see, this case reminds us to look beyond the surface. Even the most trusted figures can hide dangerous truths. And sometimes, it takes tragedy to tear the mask away.
Table of Contents