Justice at Last: How DNA, a Napkin, and Family Healing Closed a 1986 Cold Case
This article tells the heartbreaking and powerful story of Michella Welch, a 12-year-old girl from Tacoma, whose life was taken in 1986. For over 30 years, her murder remained unsolved. However, with advances in DNA technology and a napkin from a public café, the truth finally came to light.
We explore the crime, the investigation, the arrest of Gary Hartman, and how her family found healing. This story matters because it shows the strength of families, the power of science, and how justice—even delayed—can still bring peace.
A Day That Changed Everything
On March 26, 1986, 12-year-old Michella Welch went to Puget Park in Tacoma with her younger sisters. The girls were close, playful, and full of life. Michella, the eldest, was like a second mom. That day, she offered to bike home to grab lunch for everyone. It was a simple task. But when she didn’t return, panic set in.
Hours later, Michella’s bike was found—but she was nowhere to be seen. That night, police found her body in a wooded ravine near the park. She had been sexually assaulted and killed. The city of Tacoma was shaken. A little girl had disappeared in broad daylight. And the person who did it vanished without a trace.
A Case That Went Cold
Police worked hard in the early days. They questioned dozens of people and followed every lead. Forensics teams collected evidence, including a DNA sample. However, back in the 1980s, DNA testing was still in its infancy and had limited capabilities.
By 2006, police had a complete DNA profile from the crime scene. But when they ran it through national databases, there was no match. The person who hurt Michella had never been arrested. The case went cold. It stayed that way for more than three decades. But her family never gave up hope. And neither did the detectives.
DNA, Family Trees, and a New Break
In 2018, something new breathed new life into the case—genetic genealogy. This is a specialized type of DNA testing that utilizes public family history websites. Investigators partnered with experts who built a family tree from the DNA sample found in 1986.
That tree led them to two brothers. One of them was Gary Charles Hartman, a nurse who lived nearby and had no criminal record. He had seemed like a regular man, a trusted member of the community. But science was pointing right at him.
The Napkin That Spoke the Truth
Detectives followed Hartman to a local café one day. They didn’t approach him. Instead, they watched quietly. When Hartman finished eating, he wiped his mouth with a napkin and discarded it. That napkin became the key to solving the case.
Police took the napkin, tested it, and matched it to the DNA found on Michella. It was a perfect match. After 32 years, they had their suspect. Two weeks later, Gary Hartman was arrested during a traffic stop. The quiet nurse from Tacoma had a dark secret.
View this post on Instagram
The Trial and the Apology
Hartman was 70 years old when he went to trial. He chose a bench trial, which means there was no jury—only a judge. He did not deny what happened. In court, he broke down crying. He said he didn’t remember the crime. But he also said something that stuck with everyone:
“I’m so sorry. God knows I’m so sorry.”
The judge found him guilty of murder and rape. He was sentenced to 26 years and six months in prison. Because of his age, this is likely a life sentence. Hartman will spend the rest of his days behind bars.
A Family’s Long Road to Healing
For Michella’s family, the road has been a painful one. Her mother, Barbara, showed strength in court. She told the judge, “Lock him up and throw away the key.” Her voice was steady. Her love for Michella was fierce.
Nicole Eby, Michella’s younger sister, was just nine years old when her sister died. She spoke through tears and said something powerful:
“I choose to forgive Gary Hartman… When I do not, it brings death to my life.”
Forgiveness wasn’t easy. But it helped her move forward. It helped her live. The family remembered Michella as kind, bright, and full of love. She was more than a victim—she was a daughter, a sister, and a soul taken too soon.
Why This Story Still Matters Today
Michella’s case is about more than one tragedy. It shows how genetic genealogy and DNA technology can bring answers, even decades later. In recent years, this method has solved dozens of other cold cases across the country.
Police now have a powerful tool. By utilizing public DNA databases and scientific advancements, they can catch individuals who once thought they had evaded detection. And they can give families something they never had before—closure.
But this story is also about love, loss, and justice. It shows how families carry pain for years. It reminds us that every victim has a name, a face, and a story that deserves to be told.
Final Words
Michella Welch’s life was taken too soon. But the truth was never buried. It lived in a piece of DNA. It waited on a napkin. And it spoke through science, love, and courage.
Gary Hartman may have stayed silent for 32 years. But now, justice speaks louder. And while nothing can bring Michella back, her story has power. It has inspired change, brought healing to her family, and shown the world that justice never forgets.
Table of Contents