Call Me Izzy: Jean Smart’s Poetic Stand in a Grim Southern Tale
Jean Smart’s new Broadway performance in Call Me Izzy is a brave, emotional, and haunting solo act that follows a Southern woman’s private rebellion through poetry. Set in 1989 in Louisiana, the play casts Smart in the role of Isabelle “Izzy” Scutley—a housewife hiding a creative fire behind closed doors.
This article examines how the show tells her story, how Smart makes it unforgettable, and why it resonates with broader issues such as domestic abuse, personal growth, and the voices of women in silence. By focusing on both the art and the impact, this review brings readers into the heart of Izzy’s world.
A Quiet Bathroom, A Loud Rebellion
Jean Smart’s return to Broadway is nothing short of striking. On stage, she becomes Izzy Scutley, a woman from a Louisiana trailer park who speaks directly to the audience from her bathroom. The bathroom becomes a confessional.
While scrubbing the toilet, she hides her poems on toilet paper tucked into a tampon case. That first moment is both strange and deeply human. It sets up the story’s emotional core—one of isolation, resistance, and secret strength.
Izzy is a woman overlooked by the world. Her husband, Ferd, keeps her trapped and voiceless. But in private, her voice lives in words. Smart’s delivery captures the weariness of a woman worn down by years of silence and the spark of someone rediscovering herself.
Early Life and Lost Dreams
Izzy’s background is key to her pain. Once a bright, high-achieving student, she dreamed of college and independence. But at just 17, she married Ferd. He cut off her education, moved her into a trailer park, and kept her under tight control. For more than two decades, Izzy has lived behind closed curtains.
No freedom. No expression. But she finds one way out: poetry. She begins writing at night, often in the bathroom, hiding her scribbled verses where no one will find them. This act isn’t just a hobby—it’s her lifeline. Through her words, Izzy fights for the life she lost and the voice she never got to use.
View this post on Instagram
The Power of Language
One of the play’s greatest strengths is its use of language. Izzy’s poems appear throughout, painting vivid images from her daily life and hidden emotions. One poem, directed at her younger self, begins:
“To a girl of seventeen, those five years can be mistaken for charm…”
The line stings. It’s filled with regret, longing, and quiet rage.
These moments of poetry shift the show’s rhythm. We step away from the hard floor of the trailer and into Izzy’s imagination, full of color, memory, and dreams. The poems are small but mighty, like quiet explosions. They show how writing can hold pain and still offer hope.
A Solo Stage with Big Emotion
This is a one-woman show. There’s no one else to share the spotlight, and Jean Smart doesn’t need anyone else. Her performance is deeply felt—funny, bitter, gentle, and fierce all at once. She shifts effortlessly between monologue and inner reflection. One moment she’s laughing at a memory, and the next she’s caught in silence.
Despite the dark subject matter, Smart finds flashes of humor. She gives Izzy a dry wit that makes even the saddest parts more real. The audience isn’t watching a victim. They’re watching a whole, complex person trying to survive in her way.
Criticism and Complexity
Not everyone finds the play perfect. Some theater critics have raised concerns about the show’s structure and tone. They say the story leans too hard into suffering. Some call it “poverty porn”—a way of showing pain without enough care for healing or depth.
Others feel the set, locked in one bathroom scene, keeps the story too narrow. They wanted more movement, more light, or even a clearer resolution. Still, many agree that Jean Smart brings meaning to even the most difficult scenes. Her performance gives the material the dignity and weight it needs.
View this post on Instagram
Why Call Me Izzy Matters
This show isn’t just about one woman in one trailer. It speaks to countless women who’ve felt silenced, trapped, or dismissed. It tells a story about how creativity can serve as a form of resistance, especially for those without power. Izzy’s poems don’t change the world, but they change her—and that’s the point.
The play also joins a wave of solo performances that utilize simple staging to convey deeply personal stories. These shows strip theater down to its core: one person, one voice, one truth. Call Me Izzy fits that mold, even if its message can be hard to face.
The Current Run and Public Reaction
Call Me Izzy premiered on Broadway in June 2025 at Studio 54. It’s scheduled to run through August and is already sparking conversation. Audiences have responded with emotion and admiration.
Many came to see Jean Smart’s return to the stage, but they left talking about Izzy. There’s even early buzz that Smart could be nominated for a Tony. Whether or not the play wins awards, it’s clear that her performance has made a lasting impression.
A Voice That Finally Breaks Free
Izzy’s story builds slowly, moving through memories, poems, and confessions. She talks about her friend Rosalie, who encourages her to submit her poetry to contests. She describes her quiet triumphs, such as attending night classes or discreetly showcasing her work in public.
Nothing happens fast. There’s no grand escape or final confrontation. But there is growth. Izzy starts as a woman hiding from the world, and she ends as someone who knows her voice matters.
Final Words
Call Me Izzy is not an easy show to watch. It’s small, dark, and intense. But it’s also honest, poetic, and filled with heart. Jean Smart’s return to Broadway proves that one actor, one story, and one small space can say more than a full cast ever could.
The play gives a voice to someone who never had one, and through that, it speaks to everyone who’s ever felt invisible. It reminds us that art doesn’t need to be loud to be powerful. Sometimes, a poem on a scrap of paper can be the spark that ignites a revolution.
Table of Contents