DWTS Celebrity Sarah Jane Nader: Current Dating Status and Relationship History

Sarah Jane Nader, a 24-year-old actress and model who is currently competing on season 35 of “Dancing with the Stars,” appears to be single as of September 2026. However, she recently fueled romance rumors with comedian Pete Davidson after the pair were spotted together in Brooklyn. The “Love Thy Nader” star, who came out as bisexual in the first season of her Hulu reality show, is making history on DWTS as part of the show’s second all-female partnership, alongside professional dancer Hailey Bills.

As of September 2026, Sarah Jane Nader appears to be single. DWTS Season 35 contestant was recently rumored to be dating Pete Davidson after they were seen together in Brooklyn on August 2, 2026, but neither has confirmed or denied a romantic relationship. Nader, who came out as bisexual in Season 1 of “Love Thy Nader,” has previously dated Eliana Orly and Alexis Williams i

Sarah Jane Nader’s love life has drawn more attention since her “Dancing with the Stars” debut. As of September 2026, recent reports claim that Nader is still single.

But the romance rumors started swirling in early August 2026 when Nader was spotted with “Saturday Night Live” alum Pete Davidson in Brooklyn, New York. The couple was seen getting into Davidson’s car while out in Brooklyn on August 2, 2026. In the clip, Davidson can be seen holding the door open for Nader as she gets inside.

Nader and Davidson have not commented on the dating rumors, so it’s unknown if they are in a relationship. The sighting comes months after Davidson was romantically linked to model Elsie Hewitt.

In Season 1 of “Love Thy Nader,” Nader came out as bisexual in a big moment for the Louisiana native. She was candid with Variety about her journey toward self-acceptance. I kept it under wraps most of my life. Then I came to New York, and I was mostly around queer people at school. I was like, ‘Wait, that is ordinary. I can be honest about it. I do not have to hide it or hate myself for it.”

Nader was candid about her sexuality, and that extended to her family life as well. She brought home her girlfriend, Eliana Orly, for Easter to meet the family on “Love Thy Nader,” a key moment in her journey.

“It was a big moment for me because we’ve never had conversations about my sexuality,” Nader told Variety. “I’m very close with my extended family, and I love them, but it’s always kind of been something that I felt like was just ignored and even danced around.”

She’d been too scared to bring a girlfriend home before. “Before Elia,na I had a girlfriend I loved very much, but I was too scared to bring her home. I didn’t want her to have to deal with the pressure of being homophobic. “Bringing Eliana was a risk.

It was not as scary an experience as I thought it would be. I did not know. But I did not mind, ’cause she is going through Louisiana, and that was fun for me.” It took away the idea that it was going to be a really big deal. Then I carried her home, and no one said a word. “It wasn’t a big deal,” said Nader.

Nader is paired with first-time pro dancer Hailey Bills for Season 35 of “Dancing with the Stars,” only the second all-female pairing in the show’s 35-season history.

DWTS executive producer Conrad Green explained the decision to pair the two women together. Sarah Jane is bisexual, and she just wanted a woman partner. “It was just something about the dynamic of those two together,” Green told TheWrap. We kept coming back to [them] and saying, those two, they look good.

Green said Bills was excited about the pairing: “And Hailey’s totally up for it.”

Nader has described the same-sex partnership as an honor. For Season 35, Nader is partnered with first-time DWTS pro Hailey Bills, making them the show’s second all-female pairing.

The couple is only the third same-sex couple overall in DWTS history.

Nader has had many high-profile relationships, including:

Eliana Orly: Nader started dating Orly in the first season of “Love Thy Nader.” They went on a date to Henrietta Hudson, a lesbian bar in New York City, and Nader took Orly home to Louisiana for Easter.

Alexis Williams: Nader also dated Alexis Williams, who later worked on Mayor Zohran Mamdani’s campaign and was appointed deputy press secretary for the City of New York. They were never confirmed as a couple, but went on a few dates and were seen “vibing.”

Ellie Goulding: Singer Ellie Goulding appeared on one episode of “Love Thy Nader”, and fans noticed visible chemistry between Goulding and Nader. But they haven’t been photographed together since the episode aired.

Previous Girlfriend: Nader had a serious relationship before Eliana with a woman he didn’t bring home to his family for fear of homophobia.

Nader’s openness about being bisexual, and her historic DWTS partnership, has resonated with queer viewers. “People have reached out to me to tell me how my authenticity has affected them,” she told Elite Daily.

“I’ve had a few people message me that they have experienced homophobia in their family or they haven’t felt comfortable to come out and then they watched the show and felt comfortable enough to come out,” Nader said. “That’s crazy to me. I feel honored to be part of anyone’s experience, and I’m honored to have a platform to be authentically me. “That effect makes me want to be more open about more things.

“Dancing with the Stars” is currently in progress, and Nader and Bills are still competing on the show. Nader and Davidson have not made any public statements regarding their August 2026 sighting, leaving their relationship status uncertain.