Unanswered Questions: The Mysterious Death of Kimberly Fattorini and The Legal Battle That Ensued
Kimberly Fattorini, a 30-year-old Playboy casting associate, died unexpectedly in July 2017 after a night out in Los Angeles. Her death was ruled to be an accidental overdose of drugs. But years later, her parents sued, claiming foul play and negligence between former NFL player Shawne Merriman, club promoter Elias Wehbe, and others.
With the case still unsolved, it is now the subject of the true-crime series The Playboy Murders. This series looks at Kimberly’s career, the night she died, the litigation, and the growing questions about how the investigation was conducted.
Kimberly Fattorini Us An Up-And-Coming Star In The Entertainment World
Kimberly Fattorini was born on October 18, 1986, in Los Angeles. She was intelligent and ambitious, and she graduated from Whittier College as a “Notable Student” with a double major in business administration and economics.
When she graduated, she pursued her dream of working in entertainment. She found casting work with Playboy and ended up on television shows like The Hi-Life. While she wanted to be a model, she found her way in the industry behind the camera. Her career was in keeping with her ambition, glamour, and determination to make it in Hollywood.
A Night Of Partying Ends In Tragedy
On July 20, 2017, Kimberly had a night out with her best friend Monica Maass at The Highlight Room, a rooftop club in Hollywood. Promoter Elias Wehbe had invited them. After the party, they went to Wehbe’s home for more drinks.
Kimberly was later discovered unresponsive at Monica’s apartment that day. Paramedics responded at 3:30 p.m. and pronounced her dead. A toxicology report revealed alcohol, cocaine, and also GHB — a date-rape drug. Her death was ruled accidental, and the case was closed. But troubling signs remained.
Texts Suggest That Drugging May Have Occurred
Today, Kimberly’s parents are suing for wrongful death. One critical piece of evidence was a chilling text Kim had sent to Wehbe: “.. ugh but ur friend just poured half G in my drink. The “G” was believed to be an abbreviation for GHB.
Additional texts sent by Wehbe and Merriman contained derogatory terms to describe the women. One read, “Got three whores over. I’m tryna lose them so I can smash [Stefanie].” These messages were causing some serious concern about what happened that night and whether Kimberly was drugged behind her back.
The Family’s Civil Case Against Big Names
Shawne Merriman, Elias Wehbe, Monica Maass, J.P. Castro, and two clubs, Warwick and The Highlight Room, were named in Kimberly’s parents’ civil suit. They alleged negligence, battery, and a violation of the Drug Dealer Liability Act.
The lawsuit also stated Kimberly was discovered to have bruises, unzipped jeans, and no underwear, but no sexual assault examination was conducted. These details, the family believes, were indications of foul play. A civil matter remains civil, despite public interest and increasing suspicion. No one has been charged with a crime.
Was The First Investigation Mismanaged?
Detractors contend the first investigation let down Kimberly. The coroner determined her death to be accidental without a complete forensic examination. Police never followed through with sexual assault testing or thoroughly interviewing all witnesses.
When further examinations were proposed, the evidence was already impossible to gather. The family thinks that key details were missed. The public is left to wonder: Was that an accident, or was it a situation where key steps were skipped?
Public Outrage, Renewed Attention
In 2020, screenshots of the lawsuit leaked online, sparking outrage and prompting new demands for justice. Retired NFL star Shawne Merriman had publicly insisted that he had done nothing wrong, but his texts and the timing of events led many to question his involvement.
Club promoter Elias Wehbe also said no one in his camp was involved, but secret messages between him and others indicated blaming Merriman. With the story reverberating, there was pressure to reopen the case or file formal charges. To date, those calls have not resulted in arrests or criminal charges.
The Playboy Murders Reopens The Investigation
Kimberly’s story is now told in the season 3 premiere of The Playboy Murders, a true-crime series on Investigation Discovery. The episode, Last Dance, looks at her last night and her parents’ lawsuit.
Then, by examining text messages, medical reports, and witness accounts, the show offers a deeper examination of the mystery behind her death. It could also rekindle public pressure to demand justice. Read Dance of Doves. The episode airs Monday, May 5, 2025, at 9/8c.
Hollywood’s Nightlife, A Tragic Pattern
Kimberly Fattorini’s is not the only case to ring the alarm on the perils of Los Angeles nights. Young women in the industry are not strangers to situations involving drugs, unequal power dynamics, and no protections. Recreational GHB and other drug use.
The recreational use of GHB and other drugs is a rising concern. Kimberly’s death offers a chilling lesson in what can happen when safety is overlooked and investigations are incomplete. Her story has struck a chord with many seeking more accountability in elite Hollywood circles.
FAQs
Was Kimberly Fattorini’s death ruled a murder?
No. Her death had been declared an accidental overdose by the coroner in 2017.
Which drugs were in her system?
According to the toxicology report, she had alcohol, cocaine, and GHB in her system.
Who was named in the lawsuit?
Shawne Merriman, Elias Wehbe, Monica Maass, J.P. Castro, Warwick nightclub, and The Highlight Room were all listed.
Were any criminal charges brought?
There have been no criminal charges. The case is still in the civil realm.
Where can I see Kimberly’s story?
Her case is covered in the third episode of The Playboy Murders series on Investigation Discovery.
Final Words
The death of Kymberley Suchomel is still a mystery that haunts her family and the public at large. While it has been officially ruled an accident, what her parents have revealed in a lawsuit and what they have been able to share suggests something far more sinister.
As The Playboy Murders introduces her story to a national audience, many seek answers and accountability. Kimberly’s life, pregnant with promise, was taken too soon. The struggle for justice goes on, though.
Table of Contents