Behind the Scenes: The Controversy Surrounding ‘Horizon 2’
A shocking lawsuit has rocked Hollywood. Devyn LaBella, a professional stunt performer, has accused legendary actor-director Kevin Costner of violating safety protocols during the filming of Horizon: An American Saga – Chapter 2. At the center of the case is a violent, unscripted scene that allegedly took place without warning or proper protection.
The fallout has raised urgent questions about how actors are treated, who protects stunt workers, and what happens when a star steps over the line. This article looks deeper into what happened, why it matters, and what it means for the film industry going forward.
The Scene That Sparked a Lawsuit
Devyn LaBella, a respected stunt performer, says her trust was shattered. While working on Horizon 2, she was asked to act out a rape scene that wasn’t in the original script. It happened suddenly—on May 2, 2023. She claims she was not given any advance notice, no proper briefing, and no intimacy coordinator was present.
LaBella says she was not told that the lead actress had refused the scene. Instead, she was called in to take her place, without warning. She performed the scene in fear, feeling violated and trapped. Her lawsuit now seeks justice and accountability for what she endured.
Who Is Devyn LaBella?
Devyn LaBella has worked hard in the stunt world, a space where performers often risk their bodies for someone else’s spotlight. Known for her professionalism and experience, she built a reputation by performing high-impact, high-risk work safely. But LaBella says this time was different.
She didn’t sign up for humiliation or assault. She joined Horizon 2 with the expectation that Hollywood’s safety rules would protect her. When they didn’t, she felt betrayed. She now speaks up not just for herself but for other stunt workers who fear they could be next.
View this post on Instagram
Hollywood’s Rules on Consent
There are rules in place to protect performers, especially in scenes involving nudity, violence, or sex. SAG-AFTRA requires at least 48 hours’ notice for such scenes. A trained intimacy coordinator must be present. These aren’t just guidelines—they’re safeguards.
But in LaBella’s case, she says none of those protections were in place. She claims the director, Kevin Costner, pushed forward with the scene anyway. If true, this would be a significant breach of industry standards and a violation of her rights. It’s more than a legal issue—it’s a crisis of trust in how Hollywood treats its workers.
Kevin Costner Denies the Accusations
Kevin Costner, a longtime Hollywood icon, has denied the allegations. He says he had no part in forcing anyone to do anything against their will. His legal team argues that LaBella was aware of the scene details and participated willingly in the incident.
They describe her as someone with a history of complaints, trying to damage reputations. Costner insists the scene was handled professionally. For now, it’s a case of “he said, she said,” but the lawsuit is pushing both sides into the spotlight. As one of the biggest names in film, Costner’s involvement has brought massive attention to the case.
A Deeper Look at ‘Horizon 2’
Horizon: An American Saga – Chapter 2 is one of Kevin Costner’s most significant projects in recent years. It tells a sweeping story of survival and the American frontier. But behind the scenes, tension and controversy may be overshadowing the movie’s ambition.
What was supposed to be a passionate, dramatic moment on film has now become a real-world legal battle. This isn’t just about creative direction anymore—it’s about whether the people making the movie felt safe. With the lawsuit in motion, even the film’s release may be affected by the growing backlash.
View this post on Instagram
Why This Case Matters
This lawsuit is not just about one scene or one movie. It touches a nerve in Hollywood. The #MeToo movement raised awareness about abuse of power. This case raises new concerns about the extent of power directors and producers have over performers, especially those with less fame or influence.
If rules are bent or ignored, people get hurt. LaBella’s case is a reminder that even in 2025, safety on set cannot be taken for granted. It’s about more than contracts—it’s about human dignity. Performers need to know they’re protected, regardless of the production’s size.
What Comes Next for Devyn LaBella
Since filing the lawsuit, Devyn LaBella has received both support and criticism. Many in the stunt and acting communities have rallied behind her, praising her bravery. Others question her timing or motives. But LaBella remains firm.
She says she’s speaking out because the system failed her, and she doesn’t want it to forget others. She has not backed down, even in the face of Hollywood pressure. The legal process will take time, but her voice has already made a significant impact. She hopes her case will lead to stronger protections for all stunt performers in the future.
Current Status of the Case
As of late May 2025, the lawsuit is still in its early stages. No trial date has been set, but both parties are preparing for what could be a protracted legal fight. Investigators and lawyers are reviewing footage, contracts, and communication from the day of the alleged scene.
SAG-AFTRA is also closely monitoring the case. They may step in to review safety compliance and policies on future sets. Meanwhile, Horizon 2 faces delays, and some industry insiders believe the film’s success may now hinge on the outcome of this case.
Final Words
This case between Devyn LaBella and Kevin Costner is about more than two people. It’s about power, safety, and respect in an industry that continues to struggle with accountability. Whether or not Costner is found responsible, the lawsuit highlights the dangers that can arise when rules are disregarded.
Performers should never have to fear for their safety. As Hollywood continues to grow and evolve, it must also protect those who help bring its stories to life. Real change begins when people speak up. Devyn LaBella might be the voice that starts it.
Table of Contents