Nathan Fielder’s Bold Flight: How ‘The Rehearsal’ Took On Aviation Safety and Stirred the FAA
Nathan Fielder’s HBO series The Rehearsal soared to new heights in Season 2—literally. The comedian earned a commercial pilot’s license and flew a Boeing 737 to expose hidden dangers in airline communication.
His controversial findings caught the attention of the FAA, which dismissed his concerns. But the story runs deeper. From Fielder’s flying journey to behind-the-scenes tragedies faced by HBO’s Amy Gravitt, this season blends comedy, human drama, and real-world aviation risks in a way viewers won’t forget.
Nathan Fielder’s Aviation Obsession Takes Flight
Nathan Fielder has long been fascinated by aviation disasters. For nearly 20 years, he read about commercial plane crashes and noticed a recurring theme: miscommunication between pilots. On The Rehearsal Season 2, Fielder took this curiosity to new heights by training as a commercial pilot himself.
He earned his license after two years and eventually flew a complete Boeing 737 with actors as passengers. His goal? To understand pilot dynamics from the inside and to show viewers that pilot communication is still a significant safety risk in aviation.
FAA Rejects The Rehearsal Findings, Fielder Fires Back
The second season of The Rehearsal triggered a sharp response from the FAA. The agency dismissed Fielder’s claim that poor cockpit communication contributes to many crashes, stating that pilots already undergo Crew Resource Management (CRM) training.
But Fielder called this response “dumb.” Appearing on CNN, he explained that CRM training is often limited to simple PowerPoint slides, which fail to prepare pilots emotionally for real-life scenarios. Fielder argued that without immersive, practical training, communication breakdowns will continue to occur and lives will remain at risk.
Amy Gravitt’s Loss Deepens The Story
For Amy Gravitt, HBO’s head of comedy, Season 2 of The Rehearsal hit painfully close to home. In 2023, her brother Michael, a former Navy and commercial pilot, died by suicide after struggling with mental health issues linked to aviation.
His passing occurred while Gravitt was overseeing the production of the new season. Rather than pulling back, she embraced the project’s mission to spark challenging conversations about pilot culture, mental health, and the unspoken fears that can silence even experienced aviators.
View this post on Instagram
Creating An Immersive, Emotional Experience
Fielder didn’t want to merely “talk” about aviation risks—he wanted viewers to feel them. Season 2’s premiere recreated honest cockpit conversations that led to fatal crashes. Actors portrayed pilots trapped in hierarchical dynamics, afraid to speak up.
One chilling scene shows a co-pilot warning, “I can’t see,” only to be mocked by the captain moments before disaster. These recreations resonated deeply with viewers, including Gravitt, who was moved to tears while watching the season. “It’s important,” she said, “because these conversations still aren’t happening.”
Fielder’s Flight Into Danger
Even after training as a pilot, Fielder found himself caught in the very communication traps his show highlighted. During one flight lesson, an instructor insisted on flying near cloud cover without the proper clearance. Though alarmed, Fielder deferred to the instructor’s authority and didn’t intervene, despite knowing better.
Reflecting on the experience, he admitted: “I am doing a show on this thing, and I let the guy fly me into a cloud. My life was on the line, and I didn’t stop it.” His candid admission underscored just how difficult it is to speak up, even when you are aware of the risks.
Why Pilots Often Stay Silent
Fielder and aviation expert John Goglia explored why pilots—especially junior ones—hesitate to challenge their captains. Fear of career repercussions, stigma around mental health, and rigid cockpit hierarchies all play a role. Many pilots also avoid seeking therapy because it could ground them.
Fielder’s show provided a rare safe space where pilots could open up anonymously about their struggles. In one emotional montage, lonely pilots shared their burdens with Fielder’s team, highlighting the industry’s urgent need for more honest dialogue.
View this post on Instagram
The Heart Behind The Humor
While The Rehearsal is a comedy, Fielder and Gravitt approached Season 2’s weighty topic with care. Fielder worried often about balancing humor with respect. “Every joke, you think, is this too dumb? Is this too serious?” he said.
The team worked tirelessly to ensure the tone honored both the comedy roots of the show and the very real human stakes involved. Gravitt later said she felt “proud” of the final result and grateful for the years of effort Fielder put into getting it right.
A Surprise Twist In The Finale
One of the season’s most jaw-dropping moments came in the finale, when viewers learned that Fielder had fully qualified to fly a 737. Though known for blending fiction and reality in his work, this was no stunt—Fielder had truly logged the training and flight hours.
Some fans even verified his credentials in FAA records. The reveal shocked audiences and underscored Fielder’s deep commitment to understanding and highlighting aviation safety from the inside out.
Opening The Door For Change
Beyond entertaining viewers, Fielder hopes The Rehearsal sparks real change in pilot training and communication culture. He and Goglia advocate for more immersive role-playing exercises in training methods that move beyond rote slides and help pilots internalize vital communication skills.
While the FAA remains defensive, the public conversation is shifting. By blending humor, heart, and hard truths, The Rehearsal Season 2 made airline safety feel urgent and personal in a way few documentaries ever have.
Final Words
Nathan Fielder’s journey in The Rehearsal Season 2 is more than a bold television experiment. It’s a heartfelt, deeply personal mission to expose hidden dangers in the aviation world. Through his eyes—and the experiences of those like Amy Gravitt—we see how fear, silence, and stigma can jeopardize lives in the cockpit.
As debates with the FAA continue, Fielder’s message is clear: the conversation about pilot communication and mental health must go on. In an industry where lives depend on trust and clarity, no one can afford to stay silent.
Table of Contents